Large Ten vs. SEC problem: Who would win a 16-game showdown? – The New York Occasions

NCAAF
Faculty Soccer
Kickoff
LSU coach Brian Kelly is on the point of coach a mammoth season opener at Clemson. The SEC versus the ACC. Earlier this summer season, nevertheless, Kelly lobbied for the SEC to play a extra wide-ranging collection in opposition to one other league.
“Our first aim can be eager to play the Large Ten,” Kelly mentioned, after rising from an SEC coaches assembly in Destin, Fla.
Commercial
Kelly laid out what he noticed as the primary motivation: The Large Ten “holds it on the SEC” proper now after successful the final two nationwide titles, however the SEC nonetheless believes it has the deeper league. And what higher approach to discover out than a full-conference problem?
Large Ten and SEC directors have mentioned the concept over the previous yr. Nevertheless it has misplaced traction amid different debates, particularly the showdowns over the Big Ten’s preferred College Football Playoff format and the SEC’s conference schedule.
Nonetheless, what if it occurred? Final yr, earlier than it was formally mentioned, The Athletic engaged in a mock Big Ten-SEC challenge. So let’s run it again.
In our hypothetical problem, our Large Ten-based author (Dochterman) and SEC-based author (Emerson) pretended to be the convention workplaces setting matchups. We used a snake draft format, the place the SEC picked the primary staff, the Large Ten picked the staff to line up in opposition to that staff, then the second Large Ten staff, and so forth.
The consequence was marquee matchups, in addition to some “unintended” attention-grabbing video games, reminiscent of UCLA quarterback Nico Iamaleava dealing with his former Tennessee staff. Purely an accident. No hypothetical affect from tv executives!
After the matchups had been determined, we selected impartial websites. Campus video games are higher, however the function right here is to attempt to divine which groups would win on impartial fields. Plus, selecting these websites was type of enjoyable:
Location: Nashville, Tenn. Nearly an ideal midpoint between campuses, simply over an 11-hour drive from Joyful Valley and simply over a 12-hour drive from Austin. It additionally provides Tennessee Titans followers one thing price watching.
Emerson: Very a lot a prove-it-or-else season for each packages, neither of which received its convention final yr nor has a nationwide title within the final twenty years. For all the skepticism about James Franklin, it’s not like Steve Sarkisian has proven he can shut the deal both. Nonetheless, it is a wager on Texas’ roster, and sure, its quarterback residing as much as the hype. Texas, 31-23.
Dochterman: That is our prime hypothetical Large Ten-SEC matchup and it might find yourself as the true season’s remaining recreation in January. As of immediately, it’s Texas’ potential in opposition to Penn State’s manufacturing. Quarterback Drew Allar has performed in a number of massive video games and has skilled highs and lows. So has Franklin. For the season opener, that hardened edge goes to the Nittany Lions. Penn State, 27-20.
Location: Ann Arbor, Mich. Neither staff has received in The Large Home throughout their gamers’ present tenure, in order that makes it fairly darn impartial.
Commercial
Dochterman: I can solely think about the response in Columbus ought to the Buckeyes get despatched to Michigan Stadium twice in a single yr. The matchup itself is unbelievable, as was their CFP semifinal in 2022. Ohio State loses the nation’s greatest defensive position, however returns the nation’s greatest two gamers in receiver Jeremiah Smith and security Caleb Downs. It’s a four-quarter brawl, however the Buckeyes pull out a detailed one. Ohio State, 26-23.
Emerson: Georgia has the general expertise and depth to win one other nationwide title. It additionally has sufficient considerations — offensive line, whether or not the run protection will get higher, whether QB Gunner Stockton can avoid mistakes — that there’s miss-the-playoff potential. The Buckeyes appear the safer wager. Ohio State, 27-21.
Location: Denver. It’s a 19-hour drive from each campuses, not that many will wish to drive. However Denver climate within the late summer season ought to be lovely.
Emerson: Kalen DeBoer beat Dan Lanning twice in 2023, in two nice video games. That was additionally Michael Penix Jr. versus Bo Nix. What to make of Dante Moore versus Ty Simpson? It’s sufficient of an unknown that the choose leans on the remainder of the roster, the place Alabama appears to have the benefit. Alabama, 23-20.
Dochterman: Each groups have questions at a number of positions, though they’ve expertise all over the place. The very best battle is Oregon edge rusher Matayo Uiagaleilei in opposition to Alabama deal with Kadyn Proctor. The Geese dropping receiver Evan Stewart to a critical knee damage in June prevents me from punching that card. Alabama, 26-21.
Location: Memphis, Tenn. In relation to Illinois, most individuals suppose solely of Chicago. In actuality, temperature and accent are the one issues culturally that separate Downstate Illinois from the Mid-South. After all, Louisiana is completely different from everyone else.
Dochterman: This may be acquainted territory for Illinois quarterback Luke Altmyer, who grew up in Starkville, Miss. The Illini carry again 16 starters at the entire proper spots from a 10-win staff. LSU returns one of many nation’s prime quarterbacks in Garrett Nussmeier and, as all the time, one of many nation’s greatest rosters. Whereas Altmyer is terrific in late-game moments, this one is a bit a lot to deal with. LSU, 31-23.
Emerson: Bret Bielema beat LSU twice when he was at Arkansas, together with in Loss of life Valley when the Tigers had been a top-10 staff. However he wouldn’t do it this time: Kelly appears to have an urgency to win big this year, and the protection ought to lastly flip a nook, with Harold Perkins taking part in a extra pure edge-rushing spot. LSU, 27-16.
Location: Charlotte, N.C. A reasonably equidistant journey the place the 2 fan bases can meet and talk about whether or not Indiana followers would commerce their CFP look for Florida’s males’s basketball championship, and vice versa.
Emerson: What if the Gators performed Indiana’s schedule final yr? Let this recreation be a speaking level, even when this isn’t final yr’s Hoosier staff. Fernando Mendoza did switch over from Cal — SEC groups, together with Georgia, needed him — and he may very well be simply pretty much as good as DJ Lagway. However the Gators have the expertise benefit elsewhere. Florida, 37-20.
Dochterman: Oh, the Indiana slander just won’t subside south of the Mason-Dixon line. Indiana was the one staff final yr to play each CFP finalists from 2024 (Michigan, Washington) and 2025 (Ohio State, Notre Dame). The Hoosiers led the nation in level differential and run protection. They nonetheless have All-Individuals at three ranges on protection plus Mendoza. Their expertise is on par with Florida with higher teaching. Indiana, 41-26.
Location: Baltimore. It’s solely honest that the last word “Northern” state college performs the last word “Southern” state college in essentially the most culturally divided state between the areas. Jadeveon Clowney can flip the coin.
Dochterman: Was there a extra stunning bowl consequence final season than a depleted and offensively challenged Michigan roster de-pantsing a full Alabama squad? The Wolverines showcased loads of their present expertise that afternoon, and I believe it carries over. They’ll have their arms full with LaNorris Sellers however Michigan’s operating recreation ought to win the day. Michigan, 24-20.
Emerson: These are two wild-card groups in 2025. Is Michigan, after a yr of post-Jim Harbaugh transition, again in place to be a CFP staff? Is South Carolina, after a stunning yr, due for a fall, or is Sellers simply that good? Michigan, 20-19.
Location: The LAX tarmac, Los Angeles. It’s a giant airport. They’ll construct a area. And Lane Kiffin will embrace the storyline.
Emerson: There’s little query on the offenses, even with new QBs. The unknown is whether or not Lincoln Riley has discovered how you can have a serviceable protection. Kiffin did, with Ole Miss rating second within the SEC in defensive yards-per-play final yr. The Rebels did lose plenty of gamers off that unit, so it’s no slam dunk. However you simply belief them extra on each side of the ball. Ole Miss, 41-37.
Dochterman: USC was the Large Ten’s enigmatic darling final yr in upsetting LSU within the season opener, then rallying previous Texas A&M within the Vegas Bowl. The Trojans struggled in opposition to many Large Ten foes, however they had been near an excellent season. Ole Miss had a staff able to successful a couple of CFP video games final yr had it not (inappropriate metaphor) in opposition to Kentucky. USC wants a extra reliable QB (and it nonetheless may very well be Jayden Maiava) and an upgraded protection to beat the Rebels. Ole Miss, 38-36.
Location: Kansas Metropolis, Mo. Considered one of faculty soccer’s best rivalries deserves a pink carpet entrance amid a sea of pink whereas complicated TV viewers with the unbalanced pink palette within the background.
Commercial
Dochterman: Nebraska’s Dylan Raiola has the identical haircut, arm angles, mannerisms and jersey quantity as his idol, Kansas Metropolis Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes. Each groups have made offseason additions from six-win common seasons, however the Sooners have a deeper pool of expertise and wager on free-agent QB John Mateer to improve their offense. Oklahoma, 38-34.
Emerson: There are causes the Sooners are a lot of people’s pick for a giant bump this season. Mateer, improved and wholesome offensive line and receivers, and a Brent Venables protection. The Cornhuskers are additionally on the upswing, however there are extra tangible causes to select the Sooners. Oklahoma, 27-20.
Location: Salt Lake Metropolis. Persevering with the theme of groups assembly in Large 12 territory as a result of it’s barely the midpoint, and likewise Large Ten and SEC officers can do scouting for the following spherical of realignment.
Emerson: Two second-year coaches, and Texas A&M’s Mike Elko is coming off the higher first season. However the Aggies wheezed to the end, with 4 losses of their remaining 5 video games. Whereas Washington went 6-7, three of its losses had been to CFP groups, and all however one loss was on the street. Washington, 28-20.
Dochterman: Contemplating Washington misplaced 21 of twenty-two starters from a CFP finalist, Jedd Fisch had a terrific season. With attainable breakout star Demond Williams at QB plus prime operating again Jonah Coleman, the Huskies have fringe CFP potential. That wins out right here. Washington, 34-31.
Location: Munich. Iowa’s robust German heritage and zest for Oktoberfest libations nearly makes this a house recreation. Plus, it’s the fortieth anniversary of the uber-close Bo Jackson vs. Chuck Lengthy Heisman Trophy contest so excellent timing.
Dochterman: This has fistfight written throughout it regardless of the Tigers touchdown former Oklahoma QB Jackson Arnold. However Iowa lives in that world. With former FCS participant of the yr Mark Gronowski each a operating and passing risk, the Hawkeyes power a couple of turnovers and grind out an Iowa-like victory behind Logan Jones, the nation’s greatest heart. Iowa, 24-13.
Emerson: Fairly the distinction in coaches and groups. The Kirk Ferentz-led Hawkeyes, stable and hardscrabble. The Hugh Freeze-led Tigers, able to beating anybody and dropping to anybody. On this one, we’ll go along with the latter. Iowa, 16-10.
Location: Pasadena, Calif. As a result of who doesn’t wish to play within the Rose Bowl, the Volunteers have overwhelmed the Bruins there twice earlier than (1989, 1997), and it’s not just like the nominal house staff has nice attendance anyway.
Emerson: The Volunteers in all probability aren’t a CFP contender, however they nonetheless have a stable protection, and aren’t actually the Eleventh-best staff within the SEC. (As we mentioned, allowances could have been made to create a matchup.) The Bruins come by their respective convention rank extra truthfully, and even on the “street,” the Vols will present Iamaleava what he’s lacking. Tennessee, 19-10.
Dochterman: This one wants an early night kickoff as a result of Vols followers deserve an opportunity to see the solar setting over the San Gabriel Mountains. UCLA has a stitched-together roster, which suggests it could be some time earlier than we see the ultimate model. Tennessee has a greater general roster and all of the motivation lies with Rocky Prime. Tennessee, 31-18.
Location: Chicago. The Navy Pier makes an ideal locale for the Commodores versus “Row The Boat.” As for ticket gross sales, maybe the groups ought to play the sport there, too.
Dochterman: Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia stirred up Northern aggression this summer season by saying in “the Large Ten you’re not going to get beat on with the Purdue, Nebraskas.” Granted, Minnesota is not any 2024 Georgia State, however he’ll pay a worth for that one. The Gophers have a set of playmakers, led by operating again Darius Taylor and all-everything Koi Perich, who’re greater than able to rolling previous Vanderbilt. Minnesota, 34-19.
Emerson: Pavia is aware of what he’s doing. And Clark Lea is aware of what he’s doing not muzzling his star quarterback, who could make Vanderbilt attention-grabbing on and off the sphere. The ‘Dores even have greater than him: Eli Stowers may be among the finest tight ends within the nation, and the defensive entrance seven is nice sufficient to power groups to beat them by the air. Loads of groups within the SEC might nonetheless do this — however not the Gophers. Vanderbilt, 31-21.
Location: Cincinnati. A very good neutral-site metropolis, throughout the river from Kentucky and SEC territory, and nonetheless a Large Ten state. A minimum of till the SEC provides Dayton.
Emerson: Missouri falling this far appears primed for the SEC to steal a simple win. The Tigers have had two straight 10-win seasons, and QB Beau Pribula (the Penn State switch) has generated optimistic buzz. Missouri, 33-17.
Dochterman: Whether or not this recreation is aggressive or a washout is determined by which model of Michigan State quarterback Aidan Chiles seems. If he’s correct and might get the ball to underrated receiver Nick Marsh, it may be shut. However I’m not fairly there. Missouri, 31-20.
Location: St. Louis. A five-hour drive for each fan bases and the (no matter it’s known as now) Dome is sort of a excellent spot for a mid-tier bowl recreation. Think about this a trial run.
Dochterman: The Hogs and the Badgers can hoist up a can in honor of their disdain for former coach Bret Bielema, however I’m genuinely curious how Wisconsin followers would abdomen Budweiser merchandise. The Badgers’ newfound girth alongside the defensive position ought to be simply sufficient to squeeze out a victory. Wisconsin, 38-33.
Emerson: Insert the Spider-Man meme. Not solely do each have the Bielema historical past — Sam Pittman even was on his employees — these are two groups that ought to be higher than 14th of their conferences, however will not be simply due to the schedules. They should be taking part in a weaker cross-conference opponent, somewhat than one another. One other stroke of dangerous luck for Pittman. Wisconsin, 28-24.
Location: Pittsburgh. Nearly an ideal midpoint, and at this level, that’s all anybody can request. Get in, play a recreation, get house.
Emerson: The important thing for Kentucky is a grind-it-out recreation the place it makes fewer errors than the opponent. However Greg Schiano-coached groups don’t have a tendency to do this — Rutgers had a conference-low 9 turnovers final yr — and if the Scarlet Knights are even barely higher on protection, they will win this hypothetical recreation that we’re analyzing as if it’s really occurring. Rutgers, 16-12.
Dochterman: Schiano received’t land on any coach-of-the-year ballots, however he’s achieved a terrific job of turning Rutgers’ Large Ten lottery ticket into earned validation. Mark Stoops has elevated Kentucky’s gig in advantageous vogue over his tenure, too. Maybe to mark the event they may play for a double-sided Gavin Wimsatt jersey to honor each groups’ former quarterback. That’s in all probability too cute. As Seth wrote: Get in, play a recreation, get house. Rutgers, 19-17.
Location: Philadelphia. Maybe it’s not essentially impartial, however the house of the Liberty Bell will make Mississippi State’s thunderous cowbellers really feel proper at house.
Dochterman: That is the sport that will get relegated to streaming solely, however hopefully there are a couple of good highlights for wrap-up reveals on BTN and SEC Community. I’m considering how Maryland five-star freshman QB Malik Washington performs, however it’s going to take greater than that to drag folks away from the opposite 15 video games. Mississippi State, 27-25.
Emerson: And on the finish, the Large Ten-based author picks the SEC staff, whereas the SEC-based author picks the Large Ten staff. (No touch upon the place the SEC-based author obtained his diploma.) Maryland, 31-10.
Dochterman: I’ve bought the Large Ten squeezing out a 9-7 win on this jamboree. I’m nonetheless bullish on the much-maligned Hoosiers, perhaps much more than final yr, with the Large Ten successful the CFP-potential matchups 4-2. I’ll have picked in opposition to the Terrapins, however they’d nonetheless cease my Western Illinois Leathernecks, which is about 300 enlargement strikes from taking part on this train. I in all probability hedged essentially the most on USC-Ole Miss; the Trojans are higher than final yr’s report.
Commercial
Emerson: The SEC has a 9-7 edge in my picks, together with 6-2 within the prime half matchups, and 9-4 earlier than you get to the underside three matchups. This is able to assist the notion that the SEC is deeper — however not which you can by no means take per week off within the SEC. Nonetheless, Arkansas is a troublesome out, it simply drew a troublesome matchup right here. Kentucky beat Ole Miss final yr and practically beat Georgia. And Mississippi State … effectively, if Vanderbilt’s going to be good, any individual has to take its place.
(Prime picture: Joe Robbins / Icon Sportswire by way of Getty Photographs)
Spot the sample. Join the phrases
Discover the hidden hyperlink between sports activities phrases
Play immediately's puzzle

source